The Maharajah’s English Tutor

(Published in History Today, 01 January 2026)

In 1877 H.E. Sullivan, the British representative at the court of the Travancore maharajah, ventured into somewhat delicate territory: the education of the state’s young princes. As was later recorded, he ‘condemned’ the existing arrangements as offering mere book learning, without ‘training up and forming’ the children’s minds. What the British agent wanted, instead, was for the princes to be in the regular company of a ‘man of enlightened liberal views’, ‘not only in school’ but on their ‘rides and walks and travels’, so that ‘education, in its highest sense, would be going on constantly’. A ‘native’ master would not do, for:

Natives of India are not gifted with the same powers of influencing the dispositions and controlling the wills of their pupils (especially if the latter are of high rank) as are Europeans.

The ideal candidate must be an ‘English gentleman’, ‘kind, yet firm’, who would instruct his wards in ‘manly exercises as well as book knowledge’ and encourage an appreciation of ‘the beauties of nature’, and so on. But despite Sullivan’s urgings, the maharajah, Ayilyam Tirunal, turned down the proposal, not least because he himself, one of India’s most successful, respected rulers, was brought up ‘exclusively under Native tuition’. Besides, there was the issue of ‘popular prejudice’: Travancore’s people would not approve of foreigners ‘moulding’ their princes. And the maharajah belonged to his subjects first, and the Raj second.

British relations with India’s princely states were a complicated affair, often a negotiation rather than a system of absolute control. While maharajahs were often depicted as a legion of elephant-riding, spoilt, drunk, and ‘exotic’ exhibits of a dead age, such stereotypes mask anxieties on the British side. The fact is that subversion was a constant in the colonial relationship with Indian royalty. A ruler might pose obsequiously before imperial authorities while showing ‘persistent opposition’ to their policies, as was the case with a maharajah of Indore in the 1870s. ‘Native’ princes were prohibited from using terms such as ‘throne’ (the Indian term ‘gaddi’ was the officially approved one), or from calling their houses ‘royal’ (‘ruling family’ was urged). Yet in Travancore this rule was eternally flouted. Ritual and ceremony too were instruments of politics: the location of the chair of the British residents in Indian courts, for example, or whether white officers could keep their shoes on in durbars. As late as the 1930s we encounter protests that princely governments continued to deny imperial agents due honour.

Education in this context was not simply about schooling but also an avenue for politics. It was about the imperial power urging English-style training that would ready Indian princes to be modern rulers – but also loyal rulers. On the ‘native’ side, suspicion was natural: a maharajah had to manage the British, and to an extent Western education was unavoidable. But, equally, he was expected to stay true to his roots and prevent any corrosion of power. The result was that princely education became a site of tension.

One particularly illuminating case occurred at the end of the 1920s, when the Travancore maharajah was placed under a white tutor, to whose detailed, unpublished diaries we have access. And though the voice of the other party – the maharajah – is lost, much can be deduced from the tutor’s frustrated expostulations. Combined with other archival sources, we can obtain an interesting picture of attempted indoctrination and how it was countered. While there are no obvious victors or losers, what is clear is that each party possessed agency. And though the imperial government was powerful, its ability to programme a ‘native’ ruler ultimately had limits.

Travancore, in present day Kerala, was one of India’s leading princely states, with its capital at Trivandrum. Spread over 7,600 square miles, it was a well-run and prosperous country. Its Hindu maharajahs – who ruled as ‘servants’ of their family deity, Padmanabhaswamy – were consummate survivors, strategically marrying aspects of Western modernity to tradition. As early as the 1780s the maharajah Karthika Tirunal learnt English, and by the mid-19th century the language was familiar to the royals. British-inspired bureaucratic forms of government were embraced, originally as a strategy to minimise colonial supervision, but then also as a branding exercise to showcase the state’s ‘progress’. By the 1860s Travancore was lauded by the Raj as a ‘model state’. All along, the royal house remained fully committed to the state’s Hindu character, preserving traditions even when ridiculed – in fact, British interlocutors often wondered how rulers so at ease with Western idioms of thinking could still be ‘blinded’ by inherited ‘superstitions’.

Though in the 1870s maharajah Ayilyam Tirunal was not in favour of European instruction for young princes, his successor, Visakham Tirunal, modified this policy and the palace welcomed its first British tutor in 1880. But the appointment in the 1920s occurred under peculiar political conditions and during a time of conflict in the family. From the British point of view, it was not merely a question of supplying British-approved training to a prince; the prince was already the maharajah.

The dramatis personae are as follows. At the centre was Chithira Tirunal, the 16-year-old minor ruler. The Travancore family was matrilineal: the ruler’s status was inherited through his mother, not his father. Chithira Tirunal was the son of Sethu Parvathi Bayi, the junior maharani. But in 1924 when the maharajah Mulam Tirunal died, Chithira Tirunal was not yet 12. So, in keeping with custom, power was vested in the interim with the family’s eldest female member, senior maharani Sethu Lakshmi Bayi, Chithira Tirunal’s aunt. Complicating matters was the fact that the queens were estranged, so that the royal family was divided into two factions, in two separate palaces – the regent and her daughters lived in Poojappura, while the maharajah and his mother resided in Kowdiar.

Of the maharanis, the senior was conservative, popular, and highly respected – but also believed to be influenced by her unpopular consort. The junior, meanwhile, had a bad marriage and was perceived as too unorthodox, ambitious, politically ruthless, and morally suspect. For all his life and career, Chithira Tirunal was held to be – with good reason – under his mother’s thumb. With the boy set to be invested with his powers in a few years – and given longstanding British discomfort with royal women and their unpoliced domestic influence over princes – it was, as the then resident put it, to ‘prevent His Highness from being in continual association with his mother’ that the British in 1928 sent a tutor to Travancore.

G.T.B. Harvey was the 37-year-old manager of Cox and King’s travel agency at Karachi port when he applied for the post. He had had ‘a fine career at school and Cambridge’, the durbar was informed, and was ‘a good cricketer, rider, and shot’. Simply put – and mirroring the 1877 note – he was exactly the type of ‘manly’ figure the British wanted as young princes’ guardians. That the selection was not academic in intent is clear from another detail: Harvey’s interview was conducted by the Indian government’s political secretary, C.C. Watson. For this reason, the nationalist press was unhappy – as an article in the Swaraj notes, this was all a ‘callous violation both of propriety and of public interest’. Harvey knew he was not qualified to teach specific subjects; indeed, as he wrote after meeting his ward in June 1928, as far as book knowledge went, the maharajah ‘knows more than I do!’ His role, as the junior maharani saw it, was to help her son develop ‘public speaking, some fine arts’ and to cultivate a ‘general savoir-faire’. He was to be mainly a ‘companion and general guide-to-life’, but without ‘too much Europeanisation in the way of racing, bridge, billiard etc’. That would be excessive for Travancore. ‘I am’, Harvey observed, ‘to pretend to uphold traditionalism’ while, as the British agent instructed him, keeping the boy ‘friendly with his [regent] aunt and the [imperial] Government’.

Harvey was no neutral party. His writing reveals a fair amount of casual racism. Indians are described as ‘wogs’; their aesthetics were, to him, all wrong; and as the maharajah led a religious-cum-state procession he ‘wanted to laugh’ because ‘native shows’ were ‘full of stupid and undignified incongruities’. From the start he saw in the junior maharani a challenge: ‘extraordinarily well educated’, she was ‘a capable and very managing woman’. The senior maharani was ‘striking’ and ‘clever’; her consort, Rama Varma, Harvey disliked.

For their part, these figures were hardly naïve. Within two years official files would note that the junior maharani hoped to ‘get rid’ of Harvey, while the senior thought he was plotting against her husband. But they tolerated his presence; as the files show, while ‘the wishes of the family’ were an important factor in guiding the maharajah’s training, the final veto lay with the imperial power. And from the British viewpoint there were ‘manifest advantages’ to Harvey’s presence. The tutor, by his own admission, was ‘strictly loyal’, not to the maharajah but to the office of the imperial agent in Travancore.

Harvey’s first impression of Chithira Tirunal was of a ‘very shy’, ‘small undersized boy’ with a ‘deep voice [and] striking eyes’. He was friendly, but on his guard; it was open knowledge that Harvey’s goal was to distance him from his mother. The maharajah was also shrewder than he looked. He knew that during his minority he had no option but to accept the tutor foisted on him and was therefore always on his ‘best behaviour’, but used a ‘clever’ reserve to keep Harvey at a distance. After six months of service, Harvey wrote: ‘I can’t pretend to know him yet.’ He went along with most of the tutor’s plans – precluding any room for complaint – but with a pointed lack of enthusiasm. In Calcutta at the end of 1928, for example, Harvey organised a factory tour, and the maharajah enjoyed it. But as he clarified, ‘by “enjoyed”, I mean that he was politely acquiescent and interested. I haven’t seen him “enjoy” anything yet’. In 1929 we read how he was the ‘hardest boy to get an opinion out of’, and ‘I really believe that half what he says (and that’s mighty little) he doesn’t feel, and what he really feels, on any subject under the sun, he will never say!’ Later, Harvey started teaching the boy to sketch, but could not ‘tell whether he has any real interest’ in it. Every now and then the tutor thought he had finally got through, only to be disappointed. Chithira Tirunal simply would not let Harvey in.

Harvey recognised in this ‘air of priggish restraint’ a strategy to (politely) defy him. He believed that the boy was ‘coached’ to do the bare minimum. But while the junior maharani was indeed a force with which to reckon, there may have been other obstacles. By his own admission Harvey tried to get the maharajah to take an interest in ‘manly’ activities, while disapproving of the actual things the boy enjoyed: playing cards, or having fun with his (Indian) staff. In 1928 he noted how Chithira Tirunal:

whispers with his ADCs or talks in Malayalam to them, when he’s got any comment to make or joke to pass, and it annoys me that I can’t understand, nor get him to do the same to me.

Similarly, the junior maharani was a patron of Indian music, but when the maharajah listened to some records, Harvey thought this ‘the most unpleasant noise’. He was also flippant about court customs. In September 1930 he was involved in the purchase of a new car for the maharajah but was astonished that Chithira Tirunal showed no boyish enthusiasm in joining him for a test drive. Told that the maharajah only sat in a new car at an auspicious time chosen by astrologers, Harvey dismissed this, even though he knew the maharajah tended to take such beliefs seriously. It is no surprise, then, that the teenager – who all his life remained a devout Hindu – could not relate to his guardian.

The junior maharani and her court, meanwhile, had their own strategies for resisting Harvey, including weaponising durbar protocol which limited the tutor’s time with the maharajah. ‘I ride with him for an hour’, the former recorded, ‘and play games for another hour … and have two hours a day [for] lessons.’ But at ‘no other time, eg. meal times, evenings and so on can I possibly see him, it is prohibited.’ Citing caste and tradition, the British appointee was kept at bay; during periods of heightened ritual purity, such as festivals, Harvey was not even permitted to stand on the same carpet as the maharajah.

The senior maharani’s faction also succeeded in manipulating Harvey – he was delighted when funds for a tour were placed in his control (noting how he had ‘real power’ at last), not realising how this belittled the junior maharani; the ‘other palace’ wanted to deny her access to money, which she might use in plots against the senior maharani. Without sensing it, Harvey allowed himself to be used. He began to dictate terms to the maharajah’s mother, alienating her. After Chithira Tirunal turned 18 in November 1930, things got worse. The maharajah once openly accused Harvey of ‘making him unpopular with the people because all his life was being so anglicised’; that ‘he was made to look small’ because his staff obeyed not him but his tutor. The ‘real power’ Harvey so enjoyed was an affront to the ruler.

Harvey suspected – and it is likely – that the maharajah was prompted by his mother, but Chithira Tirunal’s sentiments are understandable regardless. The maharajah had a ‘full sense of his own dignity’ and would not have enjoyed being on a leash. Harvey even cultivated Chithira Tirunal’s aides-de-camp – men with whom the maharajah shared a friendly dynamic. Harvey had little access to the palace – the schoolhouse and outdoors for fixed hours was the most he was allowed – and it was through his aides that he acquired domestic intelligence. Harvey could, in a sense, justify this, because he (and the British authorities) disapproved of the family of the junior maharani living in the palace – a ‘shady’ aunt, ‘wicked’ uncles with ‘bad’ morals, and a grandmother who was a ‘senile purveyor of yarns’. Indeed, this grandmother prevailed on the junior maharani to organise a ‘black magic’ ceremony against the senior maharani: an event the aides conveyed to Harvey, who informed his British superiors, resulting in the whole family being reprimanded. But from the maharajah’s perspective, it cannot have been a pleasant experience to be cut off from his grandmother and relations, or to see his aides betray him by reporting on private events. He tried to fire the two men, only to be denied by Harvey, until he finally simply refused to speak with them at all.

After the black magic scandal the British authorities ordered that the maharajah be separated from his mother; Chithira Tirunal, with Harvey as guardian, was to be sent to Mysore state for administrative training. A bureaucrat was chosen as administrative tutor, and Harvey became, in effect, manager of the maharajah’s household for more than a year in 1930-31. His diary reveals that the maharajah conformed mechanically to Harvey’s plans, but with his trademark ‘lack of enthusiasm and enterprise’. Away from court and its strict rules Chithira Tirunal looked ‘freer’ but still lacked ‘frankness’. Harvey’s activities for the maharajah continued to bore him – he could not understand why the boy left the races early ‘to go and have his rice and skilly’; or did not enjoy anything ‘besides tennis’; or was uninterested in cricket. Whenever possible, he ‘hid himself in his apartments’ and, forced to socialise, ‘made such conversation as was necessary’. In July 1930 we read how ‘it is impossible to find distractions for him, because he has no interest in anything’. After two years in service, Harvey felt that while he ‘admired’ and ‘respected’ the maharajah, ‘I definitely do not like H[is] H[ighness]’. The feeling was mutual.

Eventually Harvey admitted defeat, writing in early 1931:

what I despair of producing in [the maharajah] is anything of the ideals we Westerners think worth having. They are merely not ideals to him or his people, and never have been, and like many other Indians who have had chances of the same sort, he will merely wait till our control is out of the way, to relapse into a mean, crafty, physically-indolent, parochial little ‘babu’.

What was worse was that in the same summer the junior maharani – through an influential associate (who Harvey described as her paramour) – persuaded the newly appointed British viceroy Lord Willingdon to amend previous plans. Instead of August 1932, as planned, Chithira Tirunal would be installed as ruler with full powers on his 19th birthday in November 1931. Willingdon also withdrew orders separating the maharajah from his mother. In giving Harvey a dressing down, the irate viceroy asked: ‘What sort of companionship do you think a boy of 17 can have with men of your age?’ – an ironic, if accurate, excoriation of generations of British policy. The junior maharani gloatingly announced to Harvey that these events would have far-reaching repercussions. She was delighted at having scored a point over the tutor.

Predictably, Harvey put in his papers. His diary ends with an account of his last encounter with Chithira Tirunal. The maharajah asked, with a feigned sweetness: ‘Is it true that you are going away?’ When Harvey confirmed his exit, there was silence. ‘Then I said, “Well, Highness. Goodbye. I wish you all good fortune, and am sure you will run your State well if only you stand on your own feet.”’ – a final broadside by the tutor, suggesting the boy was his mother’s instrument. In response he got a routine ‘Thank you’ – ‘and out we went. Not a word of thanks, appreciation, hope or regret – not a word!’ To add to the insult, at his investiture Chithira Tirunal thanked his administrative tutor and an earlier teacher, but Harvey was ignored. In his view – and in his mother’s – Harvey represented the worst of imperial overreach: an effort to control princes’ domestic lives and minds.

Harvey, of course, still believed he had done his best. His diary closes with a bitter declaration of how he had left ‘the wretched atom’ (the maharajah) ‘to the machinations and domination of his mother’. But policy concerning ‘native’ princes and white tutors was not revised. On the contrary, some years later, Harvey was appointed instructor to the young rajah of Pudukkottai. And so, the wheels of empire rolled on.